• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Decision Desk HQ

Elections Returns, Analysis and Projections

  • Home
  • Results
  • Forecasting
  • Analysis
  • Solutions
  • Contact

The Polls May Be Tightening A Bit, But Trump Is Still In Major Trouble

August 14, 2020 by Evan Scrimshaw

The great talking point of US politics right now is whether the polls are tightening or not, and whether the consequence of a tightening – a second Trump term – is more likely than it was a week ago or a month ago. The thing is, the answer to those two questions are counterintuitive – there seems to be some tightening, but it doesn’t make Trump substantially more likely to win again.

Given it will come up in this conversation, yes the 538 model is much more bearish on Joe Biden’s chances than anyone else, but that doesn’t mean that his chances have gotten better in recent weeks – it just means that 538 believes that the race has been a lot closer for a while. It isn’t like the 538 model used to be in line with the forecasters consensus and then fell out of it, they’ve been consistent in their probabilities since the late-June date their forecast has been calculated back to. (On the broader question of whether they are right to have it that close, their reputation means they cannot be dismissed).

What about the polls themselves? Well, the data is mixed there, with IPSOS, YouGov, and Morning Consult showing minimal movement, if any at all, since the week where Biden peaked with dual 15 point leads (Quinnipiac and ABC/Washington Post), but Monmouth falling to a 10% lead from an early July 13 and Fox going from an 8% the week of that peak to a 7% now. On the state polling front, recent Monmouth efforts have shown a tighter environment in polls of Georgia and Iowa, but Quinnipiac polls of South Carolina, Kentucky, and Maine show no such tightening, and SurveyUSA polling of Georgia and Kansas are quite bad for the GOP.

On the question of whether the GOP are any closer to winning the election, Nate Silver is quite helpful. His estimates, at the launch of the model, say that Wisconsin is the tipping point state, and that a 1.9% Democratic lead nationally would be enough to win the state, down from the 2.8% it would have taken in 2016. In other words, Trump’s vaunted Electoral College advantage is now small enough that a Hillary Clinton margin of popular vote victory would be enough to win the Electoral College this time – at least, more often than not. A 2% Democratic lead is a ways away from the current high single digit averages, and even if there has been some recent movement, it is a lot easier to close a lead from ~11 to ~9, and incrementally harder to move it every unit after.

Could Trump make the election a genuine Tossup by election day? Doubtful, but then again there’s basketball in August and there was just a 5OT hockey game, so 2020 doesn’t care about what used to be likely. If the Trump campaign can settle on a message instead of wasting time on false claims about Kamala Harris’ citizenship, maybe they can pull it back to something like where 538 thinks this will end up – a 6% lead on Election Day for Biden, and a wide possibility for error making a Trump win a possibility. If COVID cases decline, if the NFL season goes off mostly without a hitch, if America is seen to be getting back to a form of normal, his chances go up more. Failure to get that sense of normal back, and his numbers are probably going to stay stagnant.

At the end of the day, Trump still has a chance of winning, but at some point he runs out of time to get the polls tight enough where he can actually win. Right now, they’re not tightening nearly fast enough to think he can pull it off. Is he still in the race? Absolutely. But nothing in the last couple of weeks of polling makes him substantially likelier to win than he was a month ago.

 

Evan Scrimshaw (@EScrimshaw) is Managing Editor and Head Of Content at LeanTossup.ca and a contributor to Decision Desk HQ.

Filed Under: 2020 President, Analysis

Primary Sidebar

Sign Up for a Free DDHQ Results Account and Newsletter Subscription

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search By Category

2020 President 2022 Midterms 2023 Elections 2024 Elections 2024 President Ad Spending Analysis Covid-19 DDHQ ChatAI Delegate Count Forecasting Model Governor Guest Editorial House International Elections Mapping Methodology municipal elections News Podcast Polling Predictions Race Preview Race Update Ranked-Choice Voting Results Runoff Senate Special Election - Congressional Special Election- State Legislature State Legislative Election UK 2019 Election Uncategorized Virgina Legislative Results

Search By Month

Footer

  • Home
  • Results
  • Forecasting
  • Analysis
  • Solutions
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2021 Decision Desk HQ ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

This site uses cookies and external scripts to improve your experience.

Privacy settings

Privacy Settings

This site uses cookies and external scripts to improve your experience. Which cookies and scripts are used and how they impact your visit is specified on the left. You may change your settings at any time. Your choices will not impact your visit.

NOTE: These settings will only apply to the browser and device you are currently using.

Google Analytics

Powered by Cookie Information